Breed1Ghost said:Its possible they could have been there at all different times. I dont remember either of them talking about the island it escapes me. I thought Schierke was always in the tree with her master?
Schierke's never been there but she heard about it from Flora, and the Elf King is mentioned in many grimoires and tales. SK himself seems to know everything there's to know about the place. He's the one who told Guts that Casca could be cured.