Hi there

I know this comparison has been done to death
Well I didn't, out of curiosity what's the general consensus?
I think a huge factor would be if they are on horseback or not.
Griffith fought on horses since the beginning of the Hawks, he cut down countless of cavalry with his sword, while Serpico has basically zero military experience being an officer of the HICKS, and I doubt he fought a lot of dangerous foes on horse...
Maybe he sparred with Azan, since they are the 2 competent fighters in that bunch (mention to my man Jérôme) but that's just spéculation.
Serpico is a genius swordsman, a natural who had seemingly never been pushed before his first 2 fights with Guts (at least from his flashbacks having draws after draws against noblemen, when he could have, according to Farnese, killed them easily).
Griffith, on the other hand, is a genius swordsman and strategist with a
LOT of combat experience.
So with this one I'm going to have to go with
On horse:

>
On foot: Same thing, but closer duel.
Just my my 2¢, obviously we will never know...
It would be like... I don't know, Pippin vs Azan, both with their favorite weapon, who wins? No way to know...
Berserk is not Dragon Ball

(and I also love DBZ)
Long days and pleasant nights