I encourage you to re-read the story while paying more attention to it.
I'm not asking for advice on how to read, I'm asking for a single passage in the manga were Guts use the brand as a radar, and I'm paying attention, for every single one of your argument, as well as mine, I go verify the concerned passage to make sure my memories are rights (well, when I can, but I'll come back to that).
This is simply untrue. We see Guts rushing to Rosine's precise location in volume 15, which directly contradicts what you're saying.
As I just said I was doing, I checked the entire section, from the start of the arc in volume 14 to the moment's when Jill tell the story of Peekaf in volume 15, and here's how the arc goes:
It start around the tree where sacrificial rituals had been done, here Guts free Jill from the bandits. After that Guts and Jill travels to her town, here Guts escape when the villagers discovers Puck. Jill find him and tell him to go hide in a nearby windmill, later in that windmill, Jill explain why the villagers attacked at the sight of Puck, she explain how elves coming from the misty valley are eating the crops and kidnapping children.
So at this point, Guts as yet to sense either Rosine or a single one of her fake elves through his brand and he already know where to find them all. Shortly after that, his brand finally react, so he burst out of the windmill, and directly see the huge flying swarm of fakes elves that couldn't be missed unless you're blind. So Guts goes to the town, use a child as a bait, kill a bunch of fake elves using a barn that he set on fire, and right after that, he heard a sound, so he turn around, and Rosine is standing there on a tree. Following a small battle, Guts set up to the misty valley were he know she dwells in thanks to Jill, and since a valley is basically a huge path carved in a mountain, it's not hard to find were to go once you found the valley, who's big enough to be easily located (even more since he can just go in the direction Rosine left to find it). The next night, Jill find him fighting flamming children, and at the next morning, she finally tell him the story of Peekaf.
So, can you tell me where in all that did Guts rushed to Rosine location without any prior knowledge of where she was?
I admit it, I greatly exagerated when I said they just kind of run into each other, but your argument isn't just exageration like mine, it's plain wrong.
I don't think you really understand how the brand works...
Then explain it to me, and please tell me from where you get your explanation, as a said, I always check the manga for every argument, so you just have to point out where in the manga you get that the brand, who's only thing it can do is inflict pain on a single point, can work as a radar. (and you can go check on google, there isn't a single radar that only need a single point to work, they all need at least a 2D surface)
The brand can indeed do that, as evidenced, among other things, by the fact Casca can sense her son through hers.
We know the brand work as a radar because Casca use it like that.
And we know Casca use the brand because it work as a radar.
Great circular reasoning. Also "among other things" is the one single thing you need to prove to destroy my entire argumentation, and the only actual argumentation you made to attempt to prove it in your comment, with Rosine, was wrong.
This discussion is a complete waste of time: you're basically refusing to admit what's plain to see to any reader because you're too enamored with the incorrect assumption you came up with.
Hey, I'm trying my best, I would gladly change my opinion but when your arguments aren't plain wrong like with Rosine, you just keep repeating how I obviously didn't get the story without actually telling me what passage I'm interpreting wrong. As I said early, I always try to verify my claims in the manga before saying anything, and yet in that entire comment you just did, who's made of five different arguments, the only one I could go check was wrong. In fact, in your comment before that one, I could also only check a single one of your arguments, about the black swordsman arc, and your response to me pointing out it was wrong was with Rosine, who was even more wrong.
As i said in the comment that restarted that discussion, "if it's me that make an error of interpretation, please correct me", so could you please stop saying as argument that "It's explicitly stated somewhere in the manga that you're wrong, it's so obvious you're wrong I won't even bother to tell where it's stated", and actually tell me where it is stated, because beside two wrong examples, you have yet to do that.
