So for some reason I decided to watch this thing and write down my feedback. I hadn't seen it in 10 years, so I focused on how it differs from the manga (besides, there are no major changes from the movie version). I bet somewhere on this forum there's a post written in 2012 where I make almost the exact same observations.
Here's a couple of visual upgrades they've done though, just to give you an idea. Movie version on the left, Memorial Edition on the right.
---------
There's no opening theme, it starts right with the battle, like the movie. God, that first scene, I'd forgotten most of the birds in the sky slide by like they're on a Powerpoint presentation.
I have issues with how they depict that battle, it's trying to look epic but it's not nearly gritty enough, and Guts' introduction is trying to be flashy and cool, but not in the way that it should be. Also, the castle is shown to be standing in the middle of nowhere, literally a giant desertic plain with mountains on the horizon and nothing in between. Castles and fortified cities were typically placed in strategic areas, meaning this doesn't make sense.
I guess it's a product of how Miura depicts things in the manga. He goes straight to the point. We see the very end of the siege and a few shots of the aftermath, nothing more. It's very economical, and that's because what matters is Guts' fight. Anyway, in this adaptation Guts' talk with Bazūso before they fight is dragged out for no good reason. He plants his sword on the ground uselessly instead of attacking right away and by surprise like in the manga.
There's another thing about the axe too. In the manga, Guts is so fast that Bazūso is taken by surprise after his axe is cracked, so he hits Guts' head but not at full strength and the axe breaks. In the anime, they both do a full swing, which makes it seem like much more of a gamble on Guts' part. The adaptation also has Bazūso talk much more than he does in the manga, where he just says "w-wait" before Guts kills him. A useless addition.
When the Band of the Falcon is introduced right after that, Casca, Judo and Corcas replace the nameless men around Griffith. I honestly don't feel it's proper given the nature of their talk. I mean right after that, Corcas attacks Guts, thinking he can take him. Then why would he ask Griffith who's the strongest? It's nonsensical. After that we get a close up of Griffith's face and then of the beherit, ominously.
The opening credits from the movie are cut and replaced by a simple fade to black.
Compared to the manga, they've added scenes of women held captive, a pile of naked dead bodies with a crow feasting on them (in the middle of the fort, surrounded by people) and a crying infant rescued from a crumbled building by a monk and handed to soldiers. Not sure what the point is. It feels like they're trying to depict war crimes against civilians instead of focusing on the brutality of war itself.
The knight who was leading Guts' side is wearing gaudy jewelry and drinking wine as he talks to Guts about his pay. I guess it's to imply he plundered the castle? Or maybe he just wears tacky jewelry (that only a king would have) to battle. Either way that feels out of place and it suggests a reason for the battle that isn't coherent with the rest of the story. Also, he looks completely different from the guy on the horse that was leading the men coming through the gate. In the manga, it's the same man: he hired them to help him conquer the place. But in the adaptation, he's got a different face and armor.
There's a specific line of dialogue in this where the guy says "it's a mercenary's dream to be a knight, right?" and Guts replies "Dreams? Can those be eaten?" as he leaves. Very subtle (not). That's not in the manga of course. Instead, the scene where Guts yells at the guy not to touch him is gone. From what I recall this whole part of Guts' backstory was pretty much erased in the movies.
Oh wow, Corcas and his guys attack right off the bat. There's like 5 seconds of scenery as a transition between the castle scene and the fight. No talk beforehand, no Casca warning him, no Griffith lying in the grass. Also, I'm no expert but their horses have giant hooves, which makes them look like work horses instead of the sort of mount that was used for battle. For something purporting to be "historically researched", that's kind of a glaring mistake, but what do I know. Anyway, Corcas is made to look completely incompetent in that fight, instead of just hesitating because he's scared and then being taken by surprise.
The team is still rather lazy with the background. Just grass and stones, no shrub, no tree, nothing else. The original scene in the manga doesn't show much scenery because Miura focuses on the characters, but the wide opening shot does have trees, a ruined wall/building and a river. Another thing that jumps out to me is that all the characters seem too old in that scene (it's the voices I think), Casca especially. They're supposed to be pretty young when this happens, something like 15.
Man, they really like to change the way fights occur. In the manga, Casca fires two crossbow bolts, one hits Guts, the other misses. Then she discards her crossbow and go at him with her sword. Here they have her shoot one and keep the other trained at him while also using her sword (while on horseback). She comments on the length of his sword as she rides towards him for some reason. And Guts dismounts her by cutting her horse's rear legs rather than by overwhelming her. It's a case where Miura showed the advantage of him having a massive sword (even against someone on horseback) versus the anime having to tell you "he sure has a big sword" but not showing it being much use.
In the second part of the fight, she falls down because she stumbles on a rock (instead of Guts pushing her down through the sheer strength of his blows). Griffith throws a spear at a rather high angle.... but he's on flat land and very close, instead of being on visibly higher ground like in the manga. Makes no sense as a result. We also see the spear coming literally from the sky as if it had been thrown from far away.
Ah, I had forgotten about this. They have Griffith stop Guts' sword without moving an inch, then after 3 seconds, he counterattacks. In the manga, Griffith is in motion, charging at him with his horse, instead of standing still. Then he's made to
deflect the attack – not to bear the brunt of the hit – and counterattacks right away after Guts' sword slides off his saber. That's how the scene is even possible at all, really.
Oh, Guts doesn't get back up after Griffith strikes him down. And murmurs his name as he falls unconscious. I had forgotten how confusing they made the dream he has about Gambino while he's down. It's turned into a sort of chaotic flashback. Donovan shows up too, but it's hard to figure out anything from it if you don't already know. And like I mentioned before, they sped up that part compared to the movie, which makes it even harder to understand than it already was.
The scene with Casca is so awkward. She's still there when he wakes up, so she dresses in front of him, then punches him once, and then a second time, saying "that one's for my horse". That really drains the subtlety out of the situation, where in the manga she punches him in front of everybody, because she's angry that she was made to sleep with him to warm him up, despite her rank and status, just because she's a woman. It's like they didn't get the point, and it also makes Guts seem less cool in the process. Of course, no "black eyes" scene, nor any reflection on "touching" as she lies with him.
Griffith holds Guts' sword somewhat unnaturally, blade facing forward. In the manga the blade is backward, so it can trail behind him. Much more natural and requires less effort when carrying with one hand. Then he handles Guts' sword as if it has no weight, even as he says he could never wield it. In the manga, he holds it with two hands as he gives it back to Guts.
There's a strong focus on the beherit again when Griffith arrives, I guess to counter the fact beherits are not introduced in the Black Swordsman arc. Thing is, that kind of foreboding shot changes how the scene comes across. It detracts from Griffith himself, who's supposed to be the focus. Instead it feels like the tension and ominousness is due to that mysterious pendant. In the manga, Miura delays its introduction until a time where it's much more themetically impactful.
Rickert really gets the short end of the stick as they go through the camp. He's barely there, no different from an unnamed background character. The fight on the hill is abbreviated, removing all of Guts' thoughts about Griffith's fighting technique and generally making it less clear exactly how Griffith fights. Casca's scene with Corcas is also abbreviated, which is too bad as it helps flesh out her character and motivations (i.e. not just angry at Guts). Griffith's jump on Guts' sword is as ridiculous as I remember it, with him jumping up seemingly above Guts' height, then Guts looking left and right as if he doesn't know where his opponent went, and finally Griffith falling down as if from the sky, yet landing like a feather. Completely ridiculous.
They don't fall from the hill when Guts bites down on the saber, which makes his maneuver (to push Griffith off balance) look a lot less believable. They've also added a useless line of dialogue afterwards. No "Falcon glare" as Griffith tells Guts he is now his, unlike in the manga. Instead he looks all nice. Honestly the scene plays out like a love declaration instead of Guts being forced into servitude by an extremely charismatic man. It kinda feels like it's missing the point. Ah, and no teasing from Corcas or anything of the sort.
There's an added scene right afterwards where Guts and Griffith are, for some reason, alone on the hill and Guts' shoulder is now all but fixed. Griffith tells him that he'll get his own kingdom. This replaces the scene from after the water fight in volume 5 (where his beherit comes into play), but it feels rather abrupt and because it's so short and without context it's a lot less effective than in the manga. And... that's the end of the episode. The next one will start with skipping three years ahead and feature the confrontation with Zodd.
The ending theme is alright, but could be for any other anime series ever and you wouldn't know the difference. The visuals of the ending credits are three still images of Griffith, Casca and Guts on a black background that get a "blown to dust" effect applied to them. It's clearly made as cheaply as possible but who cares.
By the way, to compare, I quickly rewatched the '97 anime, and let me tell you that while it's not perfect by any means, it's
so much better than the 2012 version. It's somehow more faithful, more dynamically paced/edited and more to the point despite its low budget. It's kinda sad honestly.