Volume 43

Aazealh

Administrator
Staff member
Not sure it's worth making a thread for, but here goes anyway.

Release Date: August 29, 2025
Price: ¥880 (¥800 + 10% tax)
ISBN Code: 9784592166931

https://www.hakusensha.co.jp/comicslist/75529/

Volume43cover.jpg
 
What's up with all the small references? beherit, SK, femto, void, the brand.

What do they have to do with the episodes in this volume? Obviously its just because it is cool (I guess?), but why so many?
 
As soon as I saw the cover, this played in my head.

Just like vol. 42's cover, it looks like a fan art, but this time It's not as bad. It's as if someone had read vol. 43 and said "I don't like Tsug being a loser for 9 whole episodes, so I'll make him look more like Guts".
Still, there have been quite a few instances where what's depicted in some of the illustrations doesn't reflect the actual content of each episode already, and they probably won't stop with this cover. If you look at those previous instances, Tsug is never shown as depressed (or depressed at all) as he is in the continuation. So, why don't they just show that Tsug in the manga? Why do I have to look at a different iteration of the same character where he looks kinda normal but still does nothing? They probably know that no one would buy this stuff if Tsug was shown looking all derpy and sweating. It's all really sad, honestly.
 
Just like vol. 42's cover, it looks like a fan art, but this time It's not as bad. It's as if someone had read vol. 43 and said "I don't like Tsug being a loser for 9 whole episodes, so I'll make him look more like Guts".
Sure, this is an improvement on the reality of Guts' portrayal in the story, which draws attention to how lame things actually are in Berserk right now.
 
Kouji Mori has posted a message on X to advertise the coming release:

書影出ましたね。ガガの仕事はいつも本当に素晴らしい。不安と闘いながら皆さんのおかげで何とか進んでおります。この巻と次巻の章は三浦が「蝕」と同じくらい悩み苦しんだところなので本当に難しい。ただその分 何年も何十回と繰り返し相談されているところでもあるので台詞や場面はかなり正確に残せたと思う。楽しんでいただけたら嬉しく思います。ついでにDダイバーも同時発売
1f525.svg

It translates to:

The cover art is out. Gaga's work is always really amazing. Thanks to everyone, we're somehow making progress despite battling anxiety. The chapters in this volume and the next are really difficult because they are the parts that Miura struggled with just as much as he did over "the Eclipse." However, because of that, I've consulted with him dozens of times over the years, so I think we've managed to get the lines and scenes pretty accurately. I hope you enjoy it. By the way, D. Diver will also be released at the same time

This is a remarkable claim that I think needs to be addressed. Anyone can tell that the Continuation isn't faithful from the simple fact it consistently goes against what Miura had set up for the story, either ignoring or undoing the foundations and developments he'd laid out. So for Mori to claim that not only the scenes are "accurate" but so is the dialogue, well to me that means he's straight up lying. It's compounded by the fact he's admitted in the past that he struggles to remember and even understand what he supposedly knows.

As for why he would lie, it appears it's simply to advertise the coming release—while plugging his own work along with it. He's acted like that from the start, but people have tried to find him excuses for it, like having a poor memory. I get the logic. After all, the guy's an insomniac and was a boozehound for most of his life, on top of having fought in the streets for years until he almost died. You would expect some consequences. But frankly, it seems he's deliberately being dishonest here, which I find quite dispiriting.

He compares the developments in volume 43 to the Eclipse (what a joke) merely as a cheap way to emphasize that it's a big deal... and to insinuate that he personally played a big role in it, which is what he tries to do every single time he talks about Berserk. Clearly his inferiority complex does not allow him to mention his deceased friend without trying to grab some of his glory for himself. As the saying goes: "with friends like these, who needs enemies?" I used to look forward to "Mori-chan Ken-chan", his autobiography covering his friendship with Miura, but nowadays I dread it. You just know he's going to prop himself up at Miura's expense.
 
I really wish I could say Miura was resting peacefully but there's no way he is with the stuff his piece of shit "friend" has been doing for the last 3 years. I really hope something just goes ahead and puts an abrupt end to this painful journey because with each passing day it becomes harder and harder to tolerate.
 
I guess if we want to try to extract something useful from this tweet, based on what we know or we can intuit to be true, it is that the next volume should concern a development that is emotionally and story-wise extremely important, while this chapter was the set up for it.

Maybe I am reading into it too optimistically, but one thing that is probably true is that Mori knows the (very) broad strokes leading to the ending. He doesn't know how they were supposed to be executed, nor the people at studio Gaga know how to do it from scratch, but at least one "big thing" before the final confrontation between Guts and Griffith needs to happen, and he plans on delivering it somehow.

In principle there is no contradiction between the fact that the volume that just came out is completely uneventful and the fact that this section of the story, in the planning phase, would have been very hard to construct. The poor quality and uneventfulness is a Mori+studio Gaga issue, but the fact that constructing the lead up to this extreme future event was difficult is believable.

So, my optimistic takeaway is that the next volume should contain a bastardized version of a big change/event that Miura had planned as a necessary step towards the ending. Maybe afterwards someone will be able to deduce how Miura would have done it?
 
Maybe I am reading into it too optimistically, but one thing that is probably true is that Mori knows the (very) broad strokes leading to the ending. He doesn't know how they were supposed to be executed, nor the people at studio Gaga know how to do it from scratch, but at least one "big thing" before the final confrontation between Guts and Griffith needs to happen, and he plans on delivering it somehow.

In principle there is no contradiction between the fact that the volume that just came out is completely uneventful and the fact that this section of the story, in the planning phase, would have been very hard to construct. The poor quality and uneventfulness is a Mori+studio Gaga issue, but the fact that constructing the lead up to this extreme future event was difficult is believable.

What Mori is saying is really not that mysterious, he's just referring to the fact Guts is down in the dumps. He's hyping it up. And he doesn't say it was hard to construct, just that Miura was "worried" and "suffered" when he was devising it, "like the Eclipse".

Except if we look at what Miura has actually said about it over the years, it wasn't an agonizing decision for him to kill the Band of the Falcon or anything. It had been planned from the start (otherwise there'd be no Black Swordsman) and he went as far as to say he did it "with great serenity" in this Italian interview from 1996. No doubt the Eclipse demanded a lot of work to actually draw, of course, but that doesn't seem to be what Mori is talking about here.

Furthermore, in his last interview Miura said he had decided on the story "up to the latter half of the Elf Island chapter", and that he would be focusing on drawing that from now on. He knew what the main beats would be until the end, but it wasn't solidified to the point of having defined specific scenes or written dialogue, as far as we know. So that doesn't fit with Mori's account. Miura also said separately that while the story would move beyond the "journey" format, Guts would remain the main character, which I don't think is the case in volume 43.

So, my optimistic takeaway is that the next volume should contain a bastardized version of a big change/event that Miura had planned as a necessary step towards the ending. Maybe afterwards someone will be able to deduce how Miura would have done it?

You know, I'm all for giving people the benefit of the doubt, but after what we got in volumes 42 and 43, I really have no optimism left for what's to come. The believable "broad strokes" of volume 43 come down to "Guts' group meets with Silat's group" and "they fight Rakshas", neither of which required any insider info to figure out. And they were drowned in a sea of nonsensical stuff that basically retconned half the story.
 
What Mori is saying is really not that mysterious, he's just referring to the fact Guts is down in the dumps. He's hyping it up. And he doesn't say it was hard to construct, just that Miura was "worried" and "suffered" when he was devising it, "like when he drew the Eclipse".
Ah I see, I interpreted the "difficulty" and the "struggle" that Mori mentioned as a technical rather than emotional hurdle. Then yea, it barely makes any sense given the context and the interview you mentioned.

Furthermore, in his last interview Miura said he had decided on the story "up to the latter half of the Elf Island chapter", and that he would be focusing on drawing that from now on. He knew what the main beats would be until the end, but it wasn't solidified to the point of having defined specific scenes or written dialogue, as far as we know. So that doesn't fit with Mori's account. Miura also said separately that while the story would move beyond the "journey" format, Guts would remain the main character, which I don't think is the case in volume 43.
Yes sure, what Mori said since the start of the continuation that he would only show what he remembered is a massive lie. I can really only believe that he has a superficial knowledge of the essential beats, from which I concluded that well, he's gotta be approaching one soon (?).

Although, in his mind maybe some critical beats of the story have already happened in 42 and 43, and he thinks he has delivered them faithfully. Then there is no hope I guess!
 

I honestly can't even feel anger, Idk how to explain but I do not hate Mori.
It's just sad, but we already lost Miura, it can't be more sad than that.

I feel pity for him, in a way that he's a person, as Aaz said, with a sense of inferiority complex that's very hard trying to be better while shadowed by a person talent that is much greater than his, a person he presumably loves.

But he just fails, and are probably desperately trying to go up without success. Which probably explains(but does not justify) this bad behavior with these claims.

That's it, he should be a sad person, and I feel pity, poor guy, someone should put an end to his misery and cancel this project.
 
The Berserk continuation's credibility has always rested on Mori's shoulders. But with this message, Mori's credibility is ruined for me. It’s now his word against my common sense observations that the Berserk Continuation is fundamentally off track.

I used to believe we could glean some small morsels of truth by the end, but if we can’t trust Mori, then it’s over (again).

Mori could have hedged around the discrepancies by saying: The team is doing their best, working with limited material, so please support Berserk (and D. Diver!!!!). But he's instead doubling down, insisting that Volume 43's events are consistent with Miura's vision: "I think we've managed to get the lines and scenes pretty accurately."

It's a crossroads moment for those of us who have been following the Continuation. And I see two alternatives:
  1. He's telling the truth, which underscores just how poorly this team has translated Miura's ideas to the pages, and how poor his quality control is.
  2. He's lying (or exaggerating), which ruins his credibility, and nothing about the continuation—past, present, or future—can be relied upon.
Of course, you can believe what you want. Ultimately it doesn't matter what anyone believes, because the result is in the pages. Berserk isn't an entertaining series anymore. Aside from the pageantry of supporting it out of obligation to Miura's legacy, I don't know why anyone would continue reading it at this point, except perhaps to study it.
 
Back
Top