To each his own I guess...Every time I thought to myself, “Is there something wrong with me? Everyone else seems to love this game,”
Another thing is that you haven't played to it back when it has been released and obviously, it have aged.
See, I heard many times that Fallout 3 was great.
Last time I finally got it from GOG, installed it, I liked the setting at first then I started noticing every lil things I've always disliked about most western PC games. infinite useless possibilities in your choices of responses, the menus, etc.
I ended up uninstalling it, because I wasn't having fun and clearly, it wasn't for me.