What are you reading?

'Salem's Lot: It's Stephen King and vampires, so I got about what I expected to get out of it. I enjoyed it, but not as much as some of his other novels. It took my mind of getting used to my new CPAP machine last fall, so that's a major plus in my book. The miniseries scared me as a kid. That kid at the window. Ugh. No good.

The Bounty Hunters: Somehow my first Elmore Leonard novel. I've always liked the movies based off of his work, especially Get Shorty, Jackie Brown and Out of Sight, and I loved Justified, but somehow I never got around to reading his stuff until now. Really liked The Bounty Hunters. Great pulpy western stuff. I never used to like westerns, but now I just can't get enough of them.

Fevre Dream: It's G.R.R.M. and vampires, so again, I got about what I expected to get out of it. I burned through this one and had a great time with it, but for some reason don't feel that highly about it looking back all these months later. I dunno. I enjoyed it, but just can't recommend it.

Kingkiller Chronicle: I'd never heard of these books until Walter mentioned them somewhere in this thread several years ago. I finally got around to reading them and found them pretty damn enjoyable. I don't think they're the greatest fantasy novels ever written like some people do, but I also don't think they're as bad as some others say. I thought they were competently written, I liked the worldbuilding (especially his magic system and all of the artificing) and some of the characters are pretty great. Looking forward to reading The Doors of Stone if/when it comes out, but I've got lots of other stuff to read in the meantime.

Hard Freeze and Hard as Nails: Finished the last two books in Dan Simmons' Kurtz series. Hard Freeze was great. I liked it even better than Hardcase, but Hard as Nails was a let-down. I'm hoping he writes more of them, because Hard as Nails just sort of ends with the characters in limbo. Maybe he got tired of them? It certainly felt like it. Simmons is one of my favorite authors, but every now and then he has a swing and a miss. Kind of felt like it with the last one.
 
Currently I'm into Dan Ariely's Predictably Irrational about decision making and how the world around us exploit us by utilizing our irrationality. Once you start noticing how you make your decisions in your everyday life its almost feels like someone told you how a magic trick is done. Legit saved me so much money.

I'm also reading the novel of Welcome to the N.H.K. after watching the anime and being left hungry for more. It is a social commentary on the Hikikomori phenomenon in Japan where young man quit everything in their life (job, university, relationships etc) to stay at home all day - and the obvious mental and physical issue it leads to, to the individual as well as to society at large.
 
The English version of Tsutomu Nihei's latest manga, Tower Dungeon, came out today. I loved Blame, but couldn't really get into his other series. So when I heard he was doing something completely new, I preordered it.

And, well... it's completely new for him. Afterall, he's usually done science fiction manga with a special eye for creating architecture that evokes a sense of spatial horror. But Tower Dungeon is such straightforward fantasy material that I feel there has to be more happening than is immediately apparent.

Here's the back of the box blurb with the story setup:
"An evil necromancer slays the king and carries off his daughter, secreting her in the legendary Dragon Tower. To save the princess, her steadfast Royal Guard assays the stronghold, but the way is blocked by powerful eldritch creatures… So, to supplement their forces in the face of mounting casualties, they press ordinary folks from the surrounding villages into service—including Yuva, a sturdy young farmboy with a strong back but no experience in battle, and only a battered old helm and wooden shield to protect him."
Along the way, each level of the dungeon (labeled LEVEL 1 / LEVEL 50, etc) is populated with different fantasy creatures they must battle through. These monster designs and the architecture are the only standout visuals in the book. They may even be the main reason he created this setting.

I'm not necessarily down on it. It's just very basic, so far. And I really hope there's more to it.

Is anyone else reading this, and is possibly further along than me?
 
Well, listening to the podcast and having read a few issues of conan back in my day, i realized that i heard all my life a lot about HP. Lovecraft but i never ever read one of it's book, nor any cosmic horror related written book around this subject matter to be honest, even tho i met the theories of cosmic horror through many movies in my life, i never knew how much stephen king and other authors absolutely greatly inspired themselves from the content of this writer.

So i begun to listen to audio reads of his book on youtube and other places while i'm drawing...

The Call of Cthulu

Pickman's model

The Dunwich horror

The shadow out of time


It blows my mind that someone from the 1920's was capable of imagining so many futuristic and modern concepts for his time, he might have been vastly misunderstood and read like an weird excentric or someone people thought was almost crazy back in his days, now i'm interested in written testimonies of what people thought about his books and body of work at the era he published his books.
 
Last edited:
Is anyone else reading this, and is possibly further along than me?
Been reading Tower Dungeon for a couple of months and I'm up-to-date. It didn't click right away but I came to enjoy it. The art style is certainly crude - I was surprised this is the same guy who drew Blame!

The author will flesh out the world further as he goes, and the situations Yuva and co will get into as they progress into the tower are fun. Enjoy it for what it is: manga Dark Souls, if that makes sense.
 
Last edited:
The English version of Tsutomu Nihei's latest manga, Tower Dungeon, came out today. I loved Blame, but couldn't really get into his other series. So when I heard he was doing something completely new, I preordered it.

And, well... it's completely new for him. Afterall, he's usually done science fiction manga with a special eye for creating architecture that evokes a sense of spatial horror. But Tower Dungeon is such straightforward fantasy material that I feel there has to be more happening than is immediately apparent.

Here's the back of the box blurb with the story setup:

Along the way, each level of the dungeon (labeled LEVEL 1 / LEVEL 50, etc) is populated with different fantasy creatures they must battle through. These monster designs and the architecture are the only standout visuals in the book. They may even be the main reason he created this setting.

I'm not necessarily down on it. It's just very basic, so far. And I really hope there's more to it.

Is anyone else reading this, and is possibly further along than me?

I loved Blame! so I may need to check this out. I’ll let you know my thoughts if I do.
 
Well, listening to the podcast and having read a few issues of conan back in my day, i realized that i heard all my life a lot about HP. Lovecraft but i never ever read one of it's book, nor any cosmic horror related written book around this subject matter to be honest, even tho i met the theories of cosmic horror through many movies in my life, i never knew how much stephen king and other authors absolutely greatly inspired themselves from the content of this writer.

So i begun to listen to audio reads of his book on youtube and other places while i'm drawing...

The Call of Cthulu

Pickman's model

The Dunwich horror

The shadow out of time


It blows my mind that someone from the 1920's was capable of imagining so many futuristic and modern concepts for his time, he might have been vastly misunderstood and read like an weird excentric or someone people thought was almost crazy back in his days, now i'm interested in written testimonies of what people thought about his books and body of work at the era he published his books.
I really like Lovecraft. All of his cycles are amazing. I'm reading to "At the mountains of madness" by him right now. It feels so... alien and unbelievably ancient.

Also, reading the Prince of Nothing series by R. Scott Bakker. Really good stuff if you want some grimdark fantasy.
 
I finished reading Elantris about a month ago. I'd heard something about this Brandon Sanderson guy being a decent fantasy writer, so I thought I should probably check him out. In all seriousness, he's been on my reading list for some time after my friend recommended The Stormlight Archive to me. I prefer to start at the beginning of an author's work, though, so that's what I did.

It was a slow burn, but the writing was good and the characters were interesting enough to keep me going. I'm glad I finished it, because the last part of the book is a awesome and it wraps most (if not all) of the plot points up nicely.

I enjoyed Elantris enough to read the sequel short story, The Hope of Elantris, afterwards. It was decent, but not as memorable as the original.

Since then, I've been reading the Witcher series. I finished Sword of Destiny (I read The Last Wish a year or two ago) and now I'm in the middle of Blood of Elves. I'm liking the books a lot more than the Netflix series, which I found pretty enjoyable. Can't wait to play the games. :guts:
 
After finishing the Black Company trilogy again, I started up Malazan book 1, since Glen Cook himself (Black Company’s author) recommended it. Sure enough it very much feels like it was written by a Cook super fan. But it is extremely opaque, and not exactly a joy to read.

Five long chapters in, there have been several pages that are essentially interminable. The writer likes to lean on one of my least-favorite fantasy writing gimmicks—shoving a bunch of new terms in a reader’s face out of context in a disorienting way to make the world feel big and lived-in, without actually doing the work to achieve that sense.

These sorts of things, when used too often, will send my mind wandering from the page. Can you blame me? I’ve been assaulted by gangs of unexplained Capitalized Names of Things bereft of any context. In a single page, these two passages can be found: “A’Kyronis took a beating in the Panpot’son Wastes” and “The T’lan Imasse refused to acknowledge the new empress, and they marched themselves into the Jhag Ohdann”.

In instances like these, I realize I may have read a full page or even two, yet have no idea what anyone said or what happened. I’ll simply have to reread it and hope I can fend off the psychic attack this time.

I’ve read plenty, but books don’t normally disorient me like that, and I’m a Gene Wolfe veteran, so there’s something really uhh special happening with Malazan! :sweatdrop:

I’m complaining because I find this so strange, but I can’t even call this bad. There’s cool stuff here. It’s just often hard to grasp. And yes, a part of me likes solving riddles like this, but I also feel like some of this opaqueness isn’t intentional, it’s just not written by an experienced person. Oh well. I’ll definitely stick with it through the end of the first book.
 
After finishing the Black Company trilogy again, I started up Malazan book 1, since Glen Cook himself (Black Company’s author) recommended it. Sure enough it very much feels like it was written by a Cook super fan. But it is extremely opaque, and not exactly a joy to read.

Five long chapters in, there have been several pages that are essentially interminable. The writer likes to lean on one of my least-favorite fantasy writing gimmicks—shoving a bunch of new terms in a reader’s face out of context in a disorienting way to make the world feel big and lived-in, without actually doing the work to achieve that sense.

These sorts of things, when used too often, will send my mind wandering from the page. Can you blame me? I’ve been assaulted by gangs of unexplained Capitalized Names of Things bereft of any context. In a single page, these two passages can be found: “A’Kyronis took a beating in the Panpot’son Wastes” and “The T’lan Imasse refused to acknowledge the new empress, and they marched themselves into the Jhag Ohdann”.

In instances like these, I realize I may have read a full page or even two, yet have no idea what anyone said or what happened. I’ll simply have to reread it and hope I can fend off the psychic attack this time.

I’ve read plenty, but books don’t normally disorient me like that, and I’m a Gene Wolfe veteran, so there’s something really uhh special happening with Malazan! :sweatdrop:

I’m complaining because I find this so strange, but I can’t even call this bad. There’s cool stuff here. It’s just often hard to grasp. And yes, a part of me likes solving riddles like this, but I also feel like some of this opaqueness isn’t intentional, it’s just not written by an experienced person. Oh well. I’ll definitely stick with it through the end of the first book.
This is about the usual response to Gardens of the Moon, so you’re not alone in this, Walter. The opaqueness is absolutely intentional, and the series is strongly designed for re-reading, where you encounter these terms again later but with better insight. It’s like if FromSoft’s Miyazaki tried his hand at a novel: you’re supposed to piece a lot of things together. But yeah, that doesn’t exactly make for joyous reading, as you said. The first book is basically the “barrier to entry” for this series; most people drop it or finish the book and go on to read the rest of the story.

The good news, though, is that if you get past Gardens of the Moon, you will be treated to one of the strongest parts of the story, Deadhouse Gates. All the other books in the series are also better than the first one. It can only get better from there, in other words.

Also, you don’t need to read the books in order of publication, by the way. Book 3 picks up from where the first one ends. Book 5 is in a new continent entirely, with a new cast of characters and narrative. The books will all converge by the end, but the first five are not linearly connected. You can always put Gardens on the side and try Deadhouse instead, if you’re still interested.

Anyway, this series is monumental and absolutely ambitious - 10 door-stopping books totaling at around 3.5 million words. It dwarfs most other works out there. Its core fanbase makes similar claims about it that we make about Berserk (“best series ever”, etc), so you should have an idea of what you’re tackling. I’m Team Berserk though, needless to say. :guts:
 
Hello, first time posting here.

Currently reading C.S. Lewis' The Chronicles of Narnia, and for manga; Yasuhisa Hara's Kingdom (now on Vol. 36!)
Both are pretty damn good, for different reasons that's for sure!
 
At the recommendation of my gf, I have just finished reading the playscript of 'A Streetcar Named Desire' and it was... okay. I thought the depiction of Blanche's already poor mental health continuing to spiral was really sad to read, and there were some scenes and dialogue that were so vividly described that it was a little uncomfortable reading - that's a compliment! If anything it's made me curious to check out other Tennessee Williams plays.

Another thing I'm currently reading because of the missus is the manga of Tokyo Revengers! It's something I knew she was into before we were dating years back, but we've been recommending and sharing our different interests so I wanna at least give it a go for a couple volumes to talk about it with her.

But for myself, I've just finished The Gambler by Dostoevsky (I loved Crime and Punishment and The Idiot when I read them both last year), I'm also about 500 pages into Brothers Karamazov but I took a break because the murder the story is about still. hasn't. happened.
 
Just finished up the 25th novel of the Monogatari Series—Amarimonogatari.
NISIOISIN is undoubtedly one of my favorite authors. The reasons are innumerable, but his handling of trauma and its various forms (showcased throughout Monogatari, but most recently in the first arc of this novel, "よつぎバディ"/"Yotsugi Buddy") is especially worth admiring. If you're unfamiliar with the series, I guess the best label I can give is that it's a paranormal, psychological "mystery" series. However, it's more focused on the characters rather than the mystery, so I guess it's closer to a drama with a mystery framing. The mystery is the vessel for learning about the characters. In line with that, it typically doesn't focus on the trauma or situations leading to it itself, but their effects in an abstracted, paranormal manner. It sets it up to be very difficult to handle tastelessly while giving him practically infinite metaphors for the human emotions involved, which he handles creatively and immaculately. I won't dive into the nitty gritty here, better explanations exist than mine, but if you're curious, I'd suggest giving the first arc (Hitagi Crab, from the novel Bakemonogatari) a read and see if you enjoy it. It's a fantastic introduction and, honestly, pretty damn good as a standalone read.
Though I'll have to learn Japanese sometime to fully understand and appreciate the language manipulation Nisio puts to use, it's still such a fun reading experience. I need to check out his other works sometime. Though, with 100+ novels to his name, that's quite a daunting task...

I'm also going to be starting McCarthy's "The Road" soon since my friend lent me his copy and I've been sluggish in getting around to it. It'll be my first proper introduction to McCarthy, unless you count the No Country for Old Men movie.

I'll also be reading Fagles' translation of The Odyssey since my impression of Nolan's movie was relatively negative given the praise I've seen for it. (6/10 is the best I can give it, most of that score is just because of the technical impressiveness of the films creation rather than any substance within the film itself. I also found the acting quite lacking. Though, this isn't the film thread, is it?)

I may also re-read Osamu Dazai's "No Longer Human" afterward, I enjoyed that one a good bit when I read it last summer. Though, I think I'll end up tackling "Infinite Jest" instead since that's something I'm curious to read. We'll see.
 
I finally decided to read Monster by Naoki Urasawa. God, it is disappointing, to put it lightly.

Johan Liebert seems like such an intriguing character, but all the violence surrounding him and the fear the characters experienced felt inflated to me when I read chapter 16; it is a painfully tone-deaf story about a former mercenary and a little girl from Myanmar whose home he invaded, whose mother he killed, and whom he basically kidnapped as a result of some profound guilt that I’m absolutely not buying into. This man fought in CIA-backed wars and killed countless innocents for money in the poorest places in the world, and he suddenly cares for this girl because he murdered her mother in “self-defence” (she dared to point a gun at him when he entered her shack). The supposed “lesson” he is teaching the main character, Kenzo, is “that’s what happens if you pick up gun”, which is absolutely meaningless when it comes from someone who specifically uses guns to kill people for money. But the worst thing about this story is how the conflict is “resolved”: Kenzo makes some Japanese food, the mercenary fails to use chopsticks to eat it, and the girl laughs at him. When Kenzo leaves upon completing his training, the girl warms up to the mercenary and takes his hand. Seriously, she becomes cordial with her mother’s killer because he’s clumsy? Or because she had to land a hand to Kenzo a few times when he was training? How would that make her forgive him? And most importantly, how am I supposed to view Johan Liebert as this Big Evil Guy when the main character essentially befriended a war criminal?

Apparently, the real monsters were the friends Kenzo made along the way. And that’s not even a joke.

P. S. “Anti-government guerrillas in Afghanistan” my ass, just call them freedom fighters at this point, will you?
 
I didn't really care for Monster either, but I didn't have those particular hang-ups. I found the pacing of it tedious and meandering. It lost steam for me at some point, and I didn't care anymore. I recognized there were so many other things I'd rather be reading, so I dropped off around the 5th omnibus volume, which seems to be around Volume 10? Gave the books to my local library, no regrets.

I've been bouncing around various science-fiction books. Re-read Neuromancer, easily my favorite William Gibson novel. Re-read Burning Chrome, his short stories from the 70s-80s, also incredible. Then fast forwarded to the '90s, and finished his Bridge Trilogy with All Tomorrow's Parties—quite a lame (and confusing) ending to a mediocre trilogy. I admire Gibson for not being married to the exact same genre, but not all of his genre experiments pay off.

Having now read most of Gene Wolfe's work, I'm branching off into his contemporaries and discovered Damon Knight, Wolfe's first editor, credited with shaping his style early on. The first short story I could find of his—Stranger Station—was like striking gold. I've always loved first contact stories, but this one has a different angle: instead of the typical master-slave relationship, or enlightenment, it's about survival and exploitation when interactions happen between vastly different species. I particularly liked the main character's Guts-like struggle to survive despite the "rules" of the encounter having been set. Worth a read, and it's only 30 pages (free!). And like Wolfe stories, it rewards a second reading once you understand the species dynamic.
 
I didn't really care for Monster either, but I didn't have those particular hang-ups.
Well, when you start noticing the BS around all those regretful veterans and their “trauma”, you can’t unsee it. Especially when authors mention real events. But I admit, if I read this story a few years ago, I would’ve glossed over this stuff. Glad I know better now.
I've been bouncing around various science-fiction books. Re-read Neuromancer, easily my favorite William Gibson novel. Re-read Burning Chrome, his short stories from the 70s-80s, also incredible. Then fast forwarded to the '90s, and finished his Bridge Trilogy with All Tomorrow's Parties—quite a lame (and confusing) ending to a mediocre trilogy. I admire Gibson for not being married to the exact same genre, but not all of his genre experiments pay off.
Oh, I wanted to read Neuromancer as well but kinda forgot.

Honestly, when I was reading Berserk, I thought Guts and Griffith’s relationship would be more about exploitation; like, I thought Griffith was just manipulative from the start, but the Eclipse exchange shows that it is not true, and Guts wasn’t really being exploited by Griffith anyway. Still, that would have been an interesting angle, I think.
 
Johan Liebert seems like such an intriguing character, but all the violence surrounding him and the fear the characters experienced felt inflated to me when I read chapter 16; it is a painfully tone-deaf story about a former mercenary and a little girl from Myanmar whose home he invaded, whose mother he killed, and whom he basically kidnapped as a result of some profound guilt that I’m absolutely not buying into. This man fought in CIA-backed wars and killed countless innocents for money in the poorest places in the world, and he suddenly cares for this girl because he murdered her mother in “self-defence” (she dared to point a gun at him when he entered her shack). The supposed “lesson” he is teaching the main character, Kenzo, is “that’s what happens if you pick up gun”, which is absolutely meaningless when it comes from someone who specifically uses guns to kill people for money. But the worst thing about this story is how the conflict is “resolved”: Kenzo makes some Japanese food, the mercenary fails to use chopsticks to eat it, and the girl laughs at him. When Kenzo leaves upon completing his training, the girl warms up to the mercenary and takes his hand. Seriously, she becomes cordial with her mother’s killer because he’s clumsy? Or because she had to land a hand to Kenzo a few times when he was training? How would that make her forgive him? And most importantly, how am I supposed to view Johan Liebert as this Big Evil Guy when the main character essentially befriended a war criminal?
Not exactly. If you still want to give Monster a try, Keep on reading because the series makes it clear what its truly about. You are also kind of misrepresenting the entire short story. Tenma's whole charm as a character stems from his attitude towards life and how he positively impacts other people who are struggling and this is also kind of the irony. Tenma is trying to go into a world with criminals and suffering and his last goal is to "kill" Johan whereas, he himself, "helps" people find new "light" and make their lives better. He's like Ichiban from Yakuza type character.

And the gun message is pretty important to the overall story and is recontextualized throughout various parts of the series.

Obviously, if you cant connect with his character and the overall structure of the story, Monster is prolly not for you.
 
Not exactly. If you still want to give Monster a try, Keep on reading because the series makes it clear what its truly about. You are also kind of misrepresenting the entire short story.
No, I know what the author was trying to say, I’m just not buying it. I have problems with the framing of the story: I don’t think it’s good writing to have a character commit such egregious crimes and have his victim forgive him because they met another kind person. The proxy wars the story mentions are real events that hurt real people, and it is insulting to assume these crimes should be so easily forgiven, especially when the story frames the murder of the girl’s mother as an act of self-defence. I don’t think this is deliberate propaganda, but it shows a great deal of ignorance.
 
No, I know what the author was trying to say, I’m just not buying it. I have problems with the framing of the story: I don’t think it’s good writing to have a character commit such egregious crimes and have his victim forgive him because they met another kind person.
I think you are under estimating the impact Tenma's charm in Monster. Again, if it doesn't work for you, I guess it's fine. Hugo didnt "kill" the child's mother knowingly, he simply did it out of self defense which led to him develop regret and led him "adopt" the girl. So, It wasn't an "egregious crime" to say the least. It's like saying Guts is a terrible person because he killed Adonis. It wasn't intended to be, because of the chaotic situation that was there. And Tenma spent 5 months, the episode crammed it to 24 minutes(or pages) but it was a gradual impact Tenma had on their life. Obviously, it doesn't absolve Hugo of his crimes to say and what happened was a very unfortunate chain of events and very messy relationship they had(Hugo and the girl). Tenma basically helps them to move forward for a better future.

Well, when you start noticing the BS around all those regretful veterans and their “trauma”, you can’t unsee it. Especially when authors mention real events. But I admit, if I read this story a few years ago, I would’ve glossed over this stuff. Glad I know better now.
I guess, you are not going to like Monster that much because the moral of the story is simply- Society "creates" Monster and it is a very "anti killing" work. It can be beautiful to some but I can see the other side of the spectrum too.
 
I think you are under estimating the impact Tenma's charm in Monster. Again, if it doesn't work for you, I guess it's fine. Hugo didnt "kill" the child's mother knowingly, he simply did it out of self defense which led to him develop regret and led him "adopt" the girl. So, It wasn't an "egregious crime" to say the least.
It is. I told you, the reason Hugo was in Myanmar in the first place is that he invaded this country in a proxy war.
It's like saying Guts is a terrible person because he killed Adonis. It wasn't intended to be, because of the chaotic situation that was there.
It was a political assassination, not some random “chaotic situation”. And while what Guts did was bad, it is not comparable to Hugo’s crime. Guts was born into violence, he doesn’t know another life. Moreover, Guts killed a royal in his own country, who is someone higher on the social hierarchy, not some random girl from a country he invaded.
And Tenma spent 5 months, the episode crammed it to 24 minutes(or pages) but it was a gradual impact Tenma had on their life.
I am aware of that as well. But the girl’s situation is still horrific: she is away from home, she doesn’t speak the language, and she is stuck between her mother’s killer and a random man who trains to shoot. Yes, that man showed her kindness, but I fail to understand how that leads to her forgiving the murderer.
Obviously, it doesn't absolve Hugo of his crimes to say and what happened was a very unfortunate chain of events and very messy relationship they had(Hugo and the girl). Tenma basically helps them to move forward for a better future.
No, you are making Hugo sound passive. He chose this life, fighting to advance imperialist interests and kill innocents, and he never actually realised what exactly was wrong in his actions. Just guns = bad, not that he should not have been in Myanmar in the first place. This same rhetoric is used to justify and absolve war criminals in real life: it just happened to them. While in reality, they joined the military when they were 18 years old for excitement, to kill people they considered “lesser humans”. And when those “lesser humans” fight back, they suddenly cry about their PTSD. Example: Vietnam War, current genocide in Palestine.
I guess, you are not going to like Monster that much because the moral of the story is simply- Society "creates" Monster and it is a very "anti killing" work. It can be beautiful to some but I can see the other side of the spectrum too.
I agree with the message, society does create monsters. The execution is atrocious and insulting to anyone who actually knows how the world works. It’s as simple as that.
 
It is. I told you, the reason Hugo was in Myanmar in the first place is that he invaded this country in a proxy war.
We don't know what the motive of the Myanmar war was. It wasn't made clear and Urasawa simply uses real world events like fall of berlin wall or 9/11 in his stories to create an immersive background and create a very strong "hook/premise" btw. So, I don't think it is apt to think too deeply for such events.
It was a political assassination, not some random “chaotic situation”. And while what Guts did was bad, it is not comparable to Hugo’s crime. Guts was born into violence, he doesn’t know another life. Moreover, Guts killed a royal in his own country, who is someone higher on the social hierarchy, not some random girl from a country he invaded.
You are misunderstanding my point. The thing- Both Hugo and Guts didn't mean to kill the person they did( the mother and Adonis). It was a result of chaos risen from war/assassination attempt.
I am aware of that as well. But the girl’s situation is still horrific: she is away from home, she doesn’t speak the language, and she is stuck between her mother’s killer and a random man who trains to shoot. Yes, that man showed her kindness, but I fail to understand how that leads to her forgiving the murderer.
Again, you are underestimating Tenma's magnetic personality. Both Johan and Tenma are polar opposite, extremes dialed to opposite sides( other who finds no meaning in life and one who finds value in life). Tenma is a flawed human for sure, but his impact on others, is super profound and this is a recurring theme with the story(and same is with Johan but for opposite reasons). Its not a realistic story in this regards. And again, the girl slowly found reason to "smile" in form of Tenma. The "bird scene" where Tenma mentions of the nest and bird is pretty much, could be, interpreted as Hugo and the girl trying to live together and find "warmth" because they clearly will "die" out, if they lived distantly. Again, its very messy but that is the point. It stemmed from an unfortunate scene. But what they can do now is to "forgive" and end the "cycle of hatred". Its cliche for sure but you are reading a manga.
No, you are making Hugo sound passive. He chose this life, fighting to advance imperialist interests and kill innocents, and he never actually realised what exactly was wrong in his actions. Just guns = bad, not that he should not have been in Myanmar in the first place. This same rhetoric is used to justify and absolve war criminals in real life: it just happened to them. While in reality, they joined the military when they were 18 years old for excitement, to kill people they considered “lesser humans”. And when those “lesser humans” fight back, they suddenly cry about their PTSD. Example: Vietnam War, current genocide in Palestine.
You're overreaching i think. AFAIK, The story does not make any claim on what Hugo was before the military and why he joined it. Given Urasawa, he could prolly has some disturbing backstory of his own or just joined for the thrill of it like you said "excitement".
 
We don't know what the motive of the Myanmar war was. It wasn't made clear and Urasawa simply uses real world events like fall of berlin wall or 9/11 in his stories to create an immersive background and create a very strong "hook/premise" btw. So, I don't think it is apt to think too deeply for such events.
Unfortunately for authors like Urasawa, I do think deeply of such events, and I think it’s deeply irresponsible to throw them around without knowing the nature of conflict. A quick Google search tells me that Myanmar has been in civil war since 1948. A German should have nothing to do here.
Again, you are underestimating Tenma's magnetic personality. Both Johan and Tenma are polar opposite, extremes dialed to opposite sides( other who finds no meaning in life and one who finds value in life). Tenma is a flawed human for sure, but his impact on others, is super profound and this is a recurring theme with the story(and same is with Johan but for opposite reasons). Its not a realistic story in this regards.
Yes, this story is not realistic, I figured as much.
And again, the girl slowly found reason to "smile" in form of Tenma. The "bird scene" where Tenma mentions of the nest and bird is pretty much, could be, interpreted as Hugo and the girl trying to live together and find "warmth" because they clearly will "die" out, if they lived distantly. Again, it’s very messy but that is the point. It stemmed from an unfortunate scene. But what they can do now is to "forgive" and end the "cycle of hatred". It’s cliche for sure but you are reading a manga.
I honestly find it so ironic that the girl was basically taken from her “nest” (her home in Myanmar) to a different country and she will never be reunited with her family because her mother was killed. But yes, Urasawa wants the readers to interpret the scene the way you described. My point is, it doesn’t work for me.

Also, you’re basically telling me that manga is stupid and only delivers cliché messages, so I shouldn’t think too deeply about it.
You're overreaching i think. AFAIK, The story does not make any claim on what Hugo was before the military and why he joined it. Given Urasawa, he could prolly has some disturbing backstory of his own or just joined for the thrill of it like you said "excitement".
I’m not overreaching. This is how modern mercenaries behave, and I truly do not believe there’s any justification for joining the military of your country when your country is the one that instigates war.
 
you’re basically telling me that manga is stupid and only delivers cliché messages, so I shouldn’t think too deeply about it.
Not really. What am saying is what Tenma and Johan's "feats"(like johan manipulating somebody or planning that is clearly unrealistic) or impact they have, are very anime-ish, by nature. Its like a trope of shonen mangas where you fight somebody who's equal to you and you develop a very bond with them. It doesn't mean that the story doesn't have depth or you shouldn't think deeply of it.

To me, This episode is clear as day. You have to simply move on. It was a very messy thing that happened but what they can do now is to live...ig. Its idealistic but that is just Tenma. There are a lot of other moments where the characters are in a very unfortunate/tragic/twisted situation and what they can do simply is just "smile".
 
Last edited:
Not really. What am saying is what Tenma and Johan's "feats"(like johan manipulating somebody or planning that is clearly unrealistic) or impact they have, are very anime-ish, by nature. Its like a trope of shonen mangas where you fight somebody who's equal to you and you develop a very bond with them. It doesn't mean that the story doesn't have depth or you shouldn't think deeply of it.

To me, This episode is clear as day. You have to simply move on. It was a very messy thing that happened but what they can do now is to live...ig. Its idealistic but that is just Tenma. There are a lot of other moments where the characters are in a very unfortunate/tragic/twisted situation and what they can do simply is just "smile".
I think you misunderstood my entire critique. War is not just something messy that happens, there are clear reasons and instigators. The manga uses real examples and glosses over them, that’s my problem with it. You can’t simply move on from things. Justice must be delivered.
 
Back
Top