skullnights_pants said:the whole series is dark and pessimistic
Sorry but that's simply not true.
skullnights_pants said:this is a forum where we exchange ideas, its not unusual to ask other members to field their thoughts.
Indeed not, but fielding yours first is the least you could do (instead of just asserting self-made truths). So far I've provided more tangible reasons as to why Guts surviving would make sense than you have to justify your position that it wouldn't.
skullnights_pants said:as I already said, your tone of writing can come across as antagonistic at times
So can yours.