How do you feel about Metallica's new track 'If Darkness Had A Son', Griffith? As I type the track name, I can hear the riffs and entire song in my head. So it's pretty easy to remember, which's maybe a conscious effort they were going for rather than complex songwriting. It's pretty basic, straightforward.
Definitely, I wasn't impressed at first (more on that in a sec), but then I had that fucking riff and beat in my head all day and thought, "Motherfuckers did it again..." Let's go ahead and post it:
So, my first reaction, starting with the preview of the intro they released, is that it's
Eye of the Beholder! I was immediately calling it If Beholder Had a Son. Now, it's not like that's super unique as a galloping, chug riff, but at times I thought it sounded almost like a modern cover of Beholder, and the riff under the verse sounds like
a transitory one from Beholder too. Now, even that could just be a coincidence: these songs typically get built off the main riff, if you have a similar main riff, you may write similar auxiliary riffs around it, etc. It's also interesting that it's the second song that seems like a modern interpretation/interpolation of a previous one, this to Beholder as Lux Æterna is to Hit the Lights. I don't know if that's intentional, if they're merely echoing if not repeating themselves, or if it really matters (it kind of works for the concept). And structure/intent-wise, these two songs are very different, with Beholder being more aggressive, multi-faceted and complex as you say, while this is all about a vibe and a groove, much more black album or Load-like, which is what I'm anticipating from this album overall (the production and Hetfield sound great, so it should be very listenable even if the songwriting doesn't quite get all the way there, but I also think that sounds smoother and more legato, which is my preference, than the last few efforts). Metallica's not going to reinvent the wheel for like the third or fourth time and write a new Master of Puppets or Justice (they sort of tried with DM and, while fun, it's also a retread the second time), but could they do something sonically and accessibly similar to the black album or the Loads? Sure, I welcome it! Give this dad his dad rock. I'm ready for it now. =)
Metallica Nerd Corner: The lyrics, particularly the refrains of "Temptation!" and "Temptation, leave me be!" are very similar to those from an unreleased song from the Presidio sessions, which is the material that was done before James first went into rehab and then got scrapped in favor of St. Anger, as famously depicted in the
Some Kind of Monster documentary (in retrospect, they probably should have stuck with what they had =). So, a bit of a song redemption/reincarnation here, and they may be dipping into the vaults for inspiration (or it's just been on Hetfield's mind again with his relapse and divorce). Also, the line: "the unforgiven misbehaving." Nice.
Un4given confirmed!
Otherwise on the topic... I've finally gotten into and have been listening to a lot of Ghost lately, digging the first EP and three albums especially (when it was closer to an actual band than a total solo enterprise), but haven't yet reconciled how I feel about Tobias Forge turning the Pop-O-Meter to 11 on the latter two albums. I sort of hated the second half of Prequelle at first, literally turned it off, but it rocked just fine on the second try, but Impera might just be a bit too much for me. We'll see, maybe I'll come around if I can convince myself it's trying to be more Van Halen than some modern glam metal pop monstrosity. I'll probably settle on Meliora being my favorite album since it's the heaviest and most guitar driven, though I don't mind their lighter fare like the If You Have Ghost covers EP. Very pretty, and my daughter will actually let me play it in the car (it even kind of reminds me of REM, he's got that Michael Stipe nasality depending on how he uses his voice, which I don't think works as well on the more recent albums either, glam metal is more throaty =).