What's your game of the year?

Griffith

With the streak of a tear, Like morning dew
Pretty self-explanatory, feel free to share your own choices in your preferred format. Without further ado...

The 2020 Game of the Year:


Half-Life: Alyx - The game of the year you probably haven't played. It's an epic AAA franchise flagship game that happens to be made for virtual reality, the combination of which makes it like nothing else I've played in either VR or traditional gaming. It incorporates features of traditional gaming in VR and makes them exceptional, and makes features of VR feel conventional, that is to say it has a combination of technological craftsmanship, innovation and polish you won't see anywhere else. I'm replaying now with a new overhead cord VR setup, and man is it great. This is the futuristic gaming experience you were looking for in 2020 and beyond (travel to 2077 not necessary, but we'll get to that later =). Don't come to it looking for Half-Life 3, which would amount to a glorified retro experience, but something more on the evolutionary scale of Mario 64. I just don't know how accessible and replicable it is, and therefore how influential and recognized it will ultimately be. Maybe it'll have to settle for being the most high profile, cutting edge and transcendent cult game of all time; or, the best game ever nobody ever played.


Runner-ups:

Final Fantasy VII Remake - This may be a nostalgia trip and pick, but what a nostalgia trip! This is basically the gaming equivalent of trying to remake Star Wars and actually kind of pulling it off, if not always in quality, though the production value is top notch, than with apparent quantity to spare and still more to come. They'll probably still blow it... but not yet!

The Last of Us Part II - Gorgeous, moody, bloody, and exquisitely produced, but for all its apparent effort not nearly as engaging, or transcendent, as its predecessor.

Ghost of Tsushima - Gorgeous and earnest, but it's a AAA open world buffet of familiar features. Well done, though.

Doom Eternal - It's a hell of a fun gameplay loop, but almost too dependent on it to the point of being immediately repetitive, and sort of feels like a kitsch retro game experience in a modern ultra settings package. I'd have liked to have seen what would have resulted if they continued more in the vein of the 2016 version rather than going all out to the point of self-parody.

Cyberpunk 2077 - Visually impressive, ambitious, but the characters and plot are nothing special and it's basically a Bethesda game with some Rockstar sprinkled in, which is every other big game you've ever played over the last two decades. If the cyberpunk genre is your bag, great, otherwise just play Witcher 3 instead.


Special mentions:

Mortal Kombat 11 Ultimate - Technically a 2019 game, but it somehow just won best fighting game of 2020, and I've played no other game more this year or most years of my life (zeroing in on 700 hours, YIKES!). My favorite fighting game ever and it rekindled my passion for the genre.

Hades - Aaz got me into this one, but I'm not counting it because it's technically been in early access for a couple years and I only started it about a week ago, so I'll be writing a lot of impressions here. It's basically a Greek mythology themed Rogue-like, or Diablo if you prefer, with a twist: each run is until death and you make a different random build every time you play, though you can also level abilities and the story moves forward as much, or even more so, when you fail as while you progress (basically, you're always progressing, even when you die). It manages to capture that old school try 'til you die magic, without feeling like a waste of your time, plus with a lot of modern tricks and twists. The new build every time you play thing is pretty great, and it's just begging you to always try, "One more run..." The art style and story elements are delightfully charming, and the way the gameplay and storytelling naturally compliment each other should be envied by a lot of purportedly narrative driven, but actually clunkily executed, games. I also appreciate the way the references to Greek mythology actually correspond logically, even as they take intentionally irreverent liberties that result in pretty humorous commentary, unlike certain AAA franchises I won't mention (but God of War =).
 
Last edited:

Death May Die

"That day you left, that's when I knew."
Last of Us 2 for me. I loved FF7 but Last of Us 2 left a experience that really resonated with me. What a great year for games. In a gloomy world it’s really nice to have these quality escapes.
 

Aazealh

Administrator
Staff member
Man, it's hard to say! Feels like it's been three years since I played HL: Alyx, which is one of my problems with GOTY choices in general: the recent stuff always feels more relevant than the ones from the beginning of the year. In my case, Hades would have to be the game I played most over the past 3 months. I'm over it now, but I do find it excellent. FFVII Remake doesn't feel like it qualifies, even though I did everything I could in it. Loved Doom Eternal too, but not sure I'll remember much of it in 2 years. In fact I already don't remember all that much about it. In short... I don't know. Alyx might be it for me too. It pushed the envelope.
 
Half-Life Alyx sounds great for sure but I haven't played it. For me it's Cyberpunk, even tho I've had opportunity to play some of the worst performing version of the game I don't look that much on performance as I've played worse or similar performing games on my PC or PS2/PS3.

It's basically and mostly (except some cut content) what I wanted from this game which can be basically played with variety of modifications, hacking and gameplay approaches just like Deus Ex, but with even more satisfying gunplay (bottlenecked by enemy AI at some moments tho) Also this game reminds me of some action RPG classics I've played in the past, and in a good way. But this time set in very impressive looking city with lots of interiors/buildings to explore during quests and there are also fun vehicles and very disturbing dark quests to experience. It's mature and brutally realistic experience from CDPR with stunning soundtrack.
 

Dar_Klink

Last Guardian when? - CyberKlink 20XX before dying
FF7R and 13 Sentinels.
FF7 pulled off the right level of nostalgia for me even with some of the annoying bloat( that I think will plague the later parts of the series in ways Griffith brought up at some points) and the new stuff was really intriguing.

13 Sentinels, while not for everybody in terms of its characters/aesthetic, weaved together a really complicated and interesting narrative with pretty neat tactical gameplay. The way the story was told really impressed me since it took all these big reveals and had them laid out over time instead of just throwing stuff in as a big TWIST that comes out of nowhere or something that you could easily just guess from little clues at the beginning. As I played it it reminded me of a lot of specific anime/manga/movies I really enjoyed and reading an article about their influences mentioning Sukeban Deka, Please Save my Earth, Megazone 23, and Toward the Terra(among a lot of more obvious western 80s Sci-Fi movie stuff) was really validating.

FFXIV Shadowbringer's continued plot through the patches was also really good, I'm extremely excited to see what the producer and writers will do for Final Fantasy XVI. The team's practical approach to game development while pushing new talent forward is extremely refreshing and I can't wait for people who don't want to spend 600+ hours in an MMO to be able to experience it with that level of budget.
 

Griffith

With the streak of a tear, Like morning dew
The 2021 Game of the Year:

1*FAjSEdaUERk9fUuEAMuZDg.jpeg


Resident Evil Village - I've already said a lot about this game, good and bad, it's plenty flawed, but so was almost every big game I played this year, and no other had a greater sum of its parts. If you want a game that combines RE4 and RE7 into a probably lesser but fun as hell game experience, which is also a modern twist on a Universal Monster mash, this is it, and it's a pretty damn cool survival horror FPS. I ended up playing the hell out of it, including multiple NG+ runs and a new game on the hardcore difficulty, which I would have never bothered to do with those "superior" titles. Oh yeah, it also happened to incorporate my young daughter's name as the name of the protagonist's baby daughter, which definitely helped personalize it for me. So, YMMV on that. =)

Runner-ups:


veera-hokkanen-veera-hokkanen-returnal-swamp-thumbnail-veerahokkanen.jpg


Returnal - Returnal might have been my real GOTY if not for some cowardly storytelling, or story-obfuscating. It basically leaves you to choose your own interpretation, but that also leaves me wondering if I'm fooling myself with my own preference, and suspecting the creators had something much dumber in mind; more Shyamalanesque than Lynchian. Otherwise, gameplay, story progression and environmental elements are completely worthy of the honor if not for that one little thing... they fucked up the landing, which is at least thematically fitting.

B_jmiNiFcJwn191WLPm_U-3ii1LrvnpRlp7puUKnCkM.jpg


Metroid Dread - Almost a flawless return to form, including some great new tricks, but this one hasn't really stayed with me or elicited multiple replays like the two above. Otherwise, its as good as advertised.


Special Mentions:


3754811-50547636077_b9bcf10a28_c.jpg


Demon's Souls - Technically a 2020 game, but there wasn't a game I wanted to play more the last two years other than Half-Life: Alyx, and they may indeed be my favorite games of the last two years. This is basically the alpha, omega, and the cutting edge of Souls until February 25th, 2022.

Diablo II: Resurrected - Just kidding, this was sort of an obligation and chore that doesn't improve upon the original in any meaningful way. If anything it left kind of a bad taste in my mouth.

Doom Eternal: The Ancient Gods Part II - Another disappointment, possibly in part due to Covid, but it must have made them lose their figurative sense of taste, because, in addition to just being too short, the plot basically ate itself and all of Doom with it. This is like the opposite of what Doom Eternal managed to do with its ridiculous story and it's too bad this franchise seems to always end up tripping over its own dick and snapping it off.


Most Anticipated of 2022:


Elden Ring - My GOTY '22 is its to lose, though I hope I like it more for how it's different from its predecessors than how it's the same.

Sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - This should probably be at the top of the list given the incandescent transcendence of the original, but like the above; will it blow my mind like BotW all over again, or merely be a retread of it?

Horizon Forbidden West - The previous one was impressive, though it didn't hook me like the big-time franchise property its clearly aspiring to be. Maybe this one will actually get there?

God of War Ragnarök - Same as above, good but not great, but the raw materials are all there so I'm basically hoping this one transcends its predecessor.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder's Revenge - More TMNT arcade? Sure! Slim pickings though, folks. I really hope the game is about this.
 
Last edited:

Walter

Administrator
Staff member
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder's Revenge - More TMNT arcade? Sure! Slim pickings though, folks. I really hope the game is about this.
Commendatori!

I’ll have to give mine some thought. Although right now of the games i’ve played this year it’s between Alyx (yes I know) and Walkabout Mini Golf, both VR games, and Metroid: Dread.
 

Griffith

With the streak of a tear, Like morning dew
Commendatori!

You're going to like my movie of the year, which gets the nod even though 'remember when?' is the lowest form of conversation.

I’ll have to give mine some thought. Although right now of the games i’ve played this year it’s between Alyx (yes I know)

Hey, I wouldn't blame you for rolling it over, this year kinda sucked.

and Walkabout Mini Golf, both VR games,

A mini golf VR game sounds fucking awesome.

and Metroid: Dread.

You know, I said every game I played this year was flawed, but that's not true because Dread was pretty perfect for what it was.
 
Diablo II: Resurrected - Just kidding, this was sort of an obligation and chore that doesn't improve upon the original in any meaningful way. If anything it left kind of a bad taste in my mouth.
What types of ways would’ve you liked to see it improved? They’re adding a new patch to make more builds viable. Something that hasn’t been done in many years. Adding new rune words also. The only minor gripe I had was the loading que which seems to have been sorted out now.
Most Anticipated of 2022:
Sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - This should probably be at the top of the list given the incandescent transcendence of the original, but like the above; will it blow my mind like BotW all over again, or merely be a retread of it?
Nintendo needs to just accept that reusing asserts from an existing engine isn’t a bad thing. Maybe they stopped trying to reinvent the wheel every new game then we might get another Majora’s mask level of awesome.
 
I wouldn't worry about Nintendo being afraid of recycling stuff. :ganishka:
Well they only seem to do it for not good reasons.

But when it comes to their flagship games it seems like they always try to build everything from the ground up. That’s not always a bad thing either. I don’t fully understand how game development works. But they won’t have a chance of making another game like Majora’s mask if they keep doing it.

That’s what makes me most excited for the breath of the wild sequel. How much can they improve upon what they already have available? Without trying to fix what wasn’t broken.
 

Griffith

With the streak of a tear, Like morning dew
What types of ways would’ve you liked to see it improved? They’re adding a new patch to make more builds viable. Something that hasn’t been done in many years. Adding new rune words also. The only minor gripe I had was the loading que which seems to have been sorted out now.

That sounds like a good start, but since they have vanilla and LoD Diablo II options anyway, they should have just offered a third choice with more radical changes from the start. I mean, I know they're not the real D2 team and it's a risk, but have some balls and basically make it another expansion with Act VI, etc and go from there. You can always offer the original and LoD versions for purists.

Nintendo needs to just accept that reusing asserts from an existing engine isn’t a bad thing. Maybe they stopped trying to reinvent the wheel every new game then we might get another Majora’s mask level of awesome.
But when it comes to their flagship games it seems like they always try to build everything from the ground up. That’s not always a bad thing either. I don’t fully understand how game development works. But they won’t have a chance of making another game like Majora’s mask if they keep doing it.

That's if one believes Majora's Mask is so much better than those "ground up" titles, or that it's being built on OoT assets gives it an advantage. I honestly think that's more a symptom of its ingenuity to get the most out of an N64 cartridge than the cause of it.

That’s what makes me most excited for the breath of the wild sequel. How much can they improve upon what they already have available? Without trying to fix what wasn’t broken.

Let's hope so, but it was actually resembling Skyward Sword a bit more in the most recent trailer.


P.S. Can we rename this thread to remove the "2020" from the title? Another reason to let us indefinitely edit our posts. =)
 
Last edited:
I have two GotY for 2021: one that's actually a 2021 game, and one that I discovered this year.

Lost-Judgment-Steelbook.jpg

Lost Judgment - This game was another incredible installment from a very underrated developer (RGG studio). It's got everything, a great main storyline, interesting side-missions, and tons of minigames. It's one of those rare titles that will give you some food for thought and tug at your heartstrings at the same time. It helps that the combat is crazy fun too!

sMPnsa5.jpeg

Hollow Knight - This game remained under my radar for a long time, mainly because until recently, I dismissed side-scrollers and indies right off the bat. The current gen's lack of releases made me look elsewhere, and that's when I discovered this gem. It made me fall in love with an entire genre, and this should sufficiently cover everything else I would say otherwise. I can't wait for the sequel!
 
Top Bottom