Proj2501 said:
An African Zombie outbreak starring: 100% Caucasian zombies!!!! Then the fools writing these weak articles would all switch gears from RACISM to AUTHENTICITY.
While I don't agree with the article, it is an article's worth of argumentation on the subject, and so far the rebuttals on this subject in general are less than impressive (and as I tried to point out, ironic). I find the reaction to be the most odd and distasteful thing about this, almost giving the accusation credibility of some kind. In this case, you use an extreme, and obviously unlikely, example to make a labored point, followed by specious reasoning to basically belittle and dismiss those to whom this is obviously a real issue.
Proj2501 said:
Really, you didn't hear me back in the day gettin all pissy about Spanish zombies. THAT'S WHERE THE FUCKIN VIRUS WAS THAT TIME AROUND! IF IT OCCURS NEXT IN AUSTRALIA, WE'LL SEE ABORIGINEE(sp?) ZOMBIES!
That's all well in good except that there is no virus, it didn't occur anywhere, and it's not really a coincidence or case of happenstance; it's a plot device in a fictional story, which means it's subject to the same literary interpretation, including subtext and metaphor, as any such work. This genre even has a history of social commentary and underlying themes from it's beginnings to today; I'm sure many of the zombie geeks crying foul over this are the same who exult the virtues of
Dawn of the Dead for its supposed social satire and deeper anti-consumer message.
It's actually somewhat of a compliment, and step forward, that the subject matter of a video game is being taken seriously in this way. Of course, it would be nice if the great works of gaming received the same acknowledgment.
Proj2501 said:
Like Ed Norton said in The 25th Hour:
MOVE THE FUCK ON!
While I know what you mean and I'm certainly guilty of similar methods, what's the substance of this, really? I suppose a worthy and equal counter-point to this kind of display would be to quote
American History X? Or, better yet, another Spike Lee film,
Bamboozled.
Again, while I also don't agree with the accusation, I am interested in the intellectual issues in play in this debate, and I find the violent backlash and dismissal of it, and seeming need to do it, almost as troubling. Like, if someone
were trying to get away with something like this, the gamer mentality would be perfectly amenable and complicit to it; like gamers are so used to defending their games from unfair attack at this point, no questions asked, that they really could oblige anything as long as it was presented to them under the right arbitrary construct, and in the infallible cloak of the video game.
Sadly, it's like this is the paramount social issue of our generation; video games' rights!
Race issues? Definitely a secondary, if valid, concern. =)